A couple of years ago, my poor old Civic was finally relegated to the scrap yard thanks to the ever-present nasty that is the rust demon. In an ideal world, I’d have loved to repair it, but lacking the time, the storage space, and let’s be frank here, the know-how, I had no real option than to find a replacement. It went to coparts though, so at least it will help keep other civics on the road, so it’s not all doom and gloom.
This did leave me with a very short time to source another vehicle before several “cannot miss” events were due to happen, and renting one for the couple of weeks was so insanely expensive that it wasn’t worth even considering. So… off to the dealerships we go…
Flash forward 2 weeks, and I’m now an Audi driver… yes, I know, but this one has the optional indicator pack (which works for both left AND right too, it’s very clever). It’s a 2019, some 15 years newer than my Civic, and it has some new-fangled gizmos in it… like the gear shift indicator.
I’d driven things with gear shift indicators before, but they were rental vans, so I didn’t really notice they were there, but this one, being an Audi is front and centre on the dashboard and really wants to get my attention…. Purely so it can LIE to me.
I suspected it was wrong from the word go. It wanted me to be in 4th gear at 25mph. That can’t be right, surely? But no, it was a repeatable test. And 5th at 30, which was even more baffling.
So, I did some experiments, which I encourage you to try in your own vehicles to see if they apply.
Set your trip computer thingy to immediate fuel consumption and do what the shift indicator tells you. Then, drop a gear and keep the speed the same. See what happens to your mpg.
Anybody who has ridden a bicycle with gears will know how it feels. You’re in a high gear, barrelling along, you get to a tiny hill and suddenly you’re stamping on the pedals like some sort of half crazed clog dancer trying to shake a spider off their leg.
That’s happening to your engine. More effort is needed to keep the car going, fuel consumption tanks, and that poor engine is being worked harder for no good reason, and if it’s not operating efficiently, it’s going to increase the wear. On the flat, the effect is minimal but put the car under any sort of additional effort (a small hill for example), and that effect is much greater. The car will usually give you feedback in other ways that it’s time to drop a cog of course, but the common thread among the LMM community is that we enjoy all sorts of mechanical niceness, and chances are, if you’re reading this you probably rather like cars and you’re already listening out for the revs dropping or feeling for a change in vibration.
But to somebody who uses a car as a means of transport and nothing else, they probably haven’t considered it much. After all, the manufacturers know what they’re doing, so why would the gear shift indicator give bad advice?
Gear change indicators are designed to optimise fuel economy, but is it really worth the cost of engine repairs just to save a bit of fuel?
So the moral… is there one? Eh, maybe. If anything, I think it’s this.
Don’t automatically trust the computer when it tells you to do something, cause it’s you who’ll have to pay to fix it if it breaks.